logo
logo
  • Home
  • Art Supplies
  • Beads and Jewelry
  • Crafts and Hobbies
  • Art Life Today
  • Art Supplies

Create Bold Artwork With the Best Charcoal Pencils

Art Life Review Team
Written By Art Life Review Team
Last updated: Jan 22, 2025, 03:21 AM
Affiliate Disclosure ↓

Charcoal pencils are a fundamental tool in every artist’s arsenal, offering a unique blend of versatility, control, and richness in tone. These pencils are known for their ability to create a wide range of effects, from bold, intense lines to soft, subtle shading.

Our evaluation of various charcoal pencil products on the market, including their hardness levels, smudge ability, and ease of erasure, led us to the U.S. Art Supply 20-Piece Professional Charcoal Pencil Set as the standout performer. This comprehensive set delivers on all fronts, providing artists with quality, variety, and durability.

best charcoal pencils
View all Contents
  • Buying Guide: Choosing the Best Charcoal Pencils
    • Density
    • Texture
    • Hardness
    • Brands
  • Charcoal Pencils FAQs
  • Trusted Insights from Artists
  • Contributors
  • Related Reads

Our Top Picks of Charcoal Pencils

  • U.S. Art Supply Charcoal Pencils: Best Overall (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this product ↓
  • ARTEZA Charcoal Pencils: Most Versatile (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this product ↓
  • MARKART Charcoal Pencils: Best Value (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this product ↓
  • Brusarth Charcoal Pencils: Best for Blending (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this product ↓
  • Derwent Charcoal Pencils: Most Portable (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this product ↓

Detailing the Best Charcoal Pencils of 2025

U.S. Art Supply Charcoal Pencils

Best Overall
image
Check On Amazon

The U.S. Art Supply 20-piece Charcoal Pencil Set invites beginners and advanced artists alike to dive headfirst into the world of sketching with no fear! This set equips aspiring artists with all the essentials: sketch and charcoal pencils, pastels, stumps with long-lasting cores, erasers, and sharpeners, all neatly tucked away in a hard storage case.

From the exquisitely smooth charcoal pencils to the forgiving eraser, every item in this set is crafted with care and precision. We think the sturdy case makes it a great gift idea or even just good for traveling.

Product Pros
  • High-quality sketching materials
  • Suitable for beginners
  • Superior blending and shading capabilities
Product Cons
  • Doesn’t come with sketch pad
Key features/specs
High-quality pigments and materials
Soft lead for smooth coloring
Designed for excellent blending and shading
Includes 20 pieces
Long-lasting cores resistant to breakage

ARTEZA Charcoal Pencils

Most Versatile
image
Check On Amazon

If you’re learning to play around with shadows and highlights in your work and want the shading to last, the ARTEZA Charcoal Pencil Set for Drawing & Sketching is the ultimate choice. 

This set of 4 charcoal pencils, including a white charcoal pencil, and hard, medium, and soft black charcoal pencils, embraces a spectrum of blending techniques. Skilled artists and beginners alike will appreciate its versatility. Every stroke with these charcoal pencils brings images to life, while their quality ensures exceptional performance and longevity. It’s the perfect set for practicing sketching and shading.

Product Pros
  • Wide range of blending techniques
  • Suitable for any skill level
  • For rich shadows and bright highlights
Product Cons
  • Doesn’t include a sharpener
Key features/specs
Set includes 4 charcoal pencils
Pencils available in soft, medium, and hard
Suitable for sketching, drawing, and shading
Black and white tones for dynamic art

MARKART Charcoal Pencils

Best Value
image
Check On Amazon

The MARKART Professional Charcoal Pencils Set emerges as a budding artist’s perfect companion, offering exceptional value for money. These pencils effortlessly glide on the paper, ensuring seamless blending and shading.

With 5 soft, 3 medium, and 2 hard charcoal pencils in the set, you can easily transition between various intensities to create depth and dimension. Their versatility allows you to explore different styles and techniques, truly making them a must-have tool in your sketching arsenal. If you are looking for a budget-friendly option that does not compromise on quality, this charcoal pencil set is the best option to start getting your work on the page.

Product Pros
  • Easy to blend and layer
  • Provides varying degrees of hardness
  • Great value for money
Product Cons
  • Doesn’t include erasers
Key features/specs
10-piece charcoal pencil set
Includes soft, medium, and hard grades
Conforms to ASTM D-4236 and EN71 standards
Non-toxic and eco-friendly materials
High pigmentation for rich colors
Easy to sharpen pencils
Ideal for detailed and broad strokes

Brusarth Charcoal Pencils

Best for Blending
image
Check On Amazon

Whether you’re a novice artist looking to experiment with charcoal or an experienced artist seeking an affordable yet effective charcoal set, the Brusarth’s 12-piece Charcoal Drawing Set is worth considering. This kit includes black and white charcoal pencils, eraser pencils, and blending stumps, offering a comprehensive package for drawing, sketching, and shading.

The black charcoal pencils excel in creating intense, rich lines, while the white charcoal pencils shine when highlighting and laying down tones on dark surfaces. This dynamic duo allows artists to explore contrast and depth effectively. I love that this set includes both extra soft, soft, medium, and hard charcoal pencils, giving you all of the best tools to truly take your charcoal drawings to the next level.

Product Pros
  • Works well on dark surfaces
  • Erases easily without residue
  • Pencils blend very easily
Product Cons
  • No sharpener included
Key features/specs
Works well on dark surfaces
Erases easily without residue
Pencils blend very easily

Derwent Charcoal Pencils

Most Portable
image
Check On Amazon

The Derwent Charcoal Pencils are made with high-quality charcoal and precision that allows you to take control over your work. The pencils craft a smooth, rich darkness and they shine in their versatility for shading. They offer the perfect balance between soft subtlety and strong, bold strokes.

We love the very retro metal tin carrying case they come in, which makes them both more portable and easier to identify in your art supply bin or bag. It also includes a white charcoal pencil and pencils in varying hardness levels.

Product Pros
  • High quality and smooth texture
  • Great for shading and blending
  • Comes in a durable metal tin
Product Cons
  • Does not include an eraser
Key features/specs
Composed of charcoal particles and clay
Smooth texture for easy blending
Set of 6 pencils
Comes with a metal tin and sharpener

Buying Guide: Choosing the Best Charcoal Pencils

When it comes to sketching and drawing, nothing beats the feel and result of a top-quality charcoal pencil. These tools provide an unmatched level of depth, texture, and contrast to your artwork. However, there are a few things to consider when you’re looking for charcoal pencils to purchase. This buying guide will provide you with all the essential information you need to make an informed decision and invest wisely in your art supplies.

Density

The density of the charcoal in your pencil plays a significant role in the overall quality of your drawings. High-density pencils create bold and dark lines, ideal for detailing and shading. On the other hand, low-density pencils produce lighter strokes and are perfect for initial sketches and gentle shading. Therefore, consider the kind of work you’ll be doing before choosing your charcoal pencils.

Texture

The texture of the charcoal affects the smoothness of your sketching experience. When it comes to texture, you don’t want a pencil that merely “feels good,” but one that glides across the paper, making each stroke effortless. A smooth texture will reduce friction and allow for a more fluid drawing experience, while a rough texture will give your artwork a unique gritty look.

Hardness

The hardness of a charcoal pencil determines the variation of tones and shades you can achieve in your drawings. Seek out pencils that can create a range of tones from light greys to deep blacks. Hard charcoal pencils produce lighter lines, while soft charcoal pencils produce darker, more prominent lines.

Brands

Brands often play a role in the quality and reliability of charcoal pencils. Although it’s not just about buying from a reputable brand, you should aim to choose brands that consistently deliver quality and earn positive reviews from artists.

Charcoal Pencils FAQs

What's the difference between charcoal pencils and regular graphite pencils?

Charcoal pencils contain compressed charcoal as the core, providing a much darker and richer black than graphite pencils. They're perfect for creating deep shadows and bold, expressive lines.

Do charcoal pencils come in different grades like graphite pencils?

Yes, charcoal pencils are available in different grades, ranging from soft to hard. Soft charcoal pencils, around 6B, produce darker, more intense lines, while hard charcoal pencils, around 2H, create lighter, finer lines. The grading system is similar to graphite pencils.

Can I erase charcoal pencil marks easily?

Charcoal marks are generally more difficult to erase compared to graphite. While you can use a kneaded eraser or a vinyl eraser, expect some residual marks, especially on rough paper. It's often best to embrace mistakes and incorporate them into your artwork.

What's the difference between vine and compressed charcoal?

Vine charcoal is soft and powdery, perfect for creating initial sketches or broad strokes. Compressed charcoal, found in charcoal pencils, is denser and produces darker lines. It's great for adding details and achieving richer blacks.

Can I blend charcoal pencil marks?

Yes, charcoal pencils are easily blendable. You can use blending stumps, tortillons, or even your fingers to blend charcoal marks on paper. This technique is great for creating smooth gradients and soft transitions.

Do I need special paper for charcoal pencils?

While you can use regular drawing paper, it's best to use paper specifically designed for charcoal. Charcoal paper is thicker and has a rougher texture, which helps grip the charcoal and prevents smudging. Additionally, it can handle multiple layers of charcoal without buckling.

Trusted Insights from Artists

At Art Life Today, our passion for arts and crafts is at the heart of everything we do. We understand that the right tools and materials can make all the difference in your creative projects, so we take our responsibility as reviewers seriously. Our goal is to help you discover the best products that will inspire your creativity and bring your artistic visions to life.

Contributors

Art Life Review Team
Art Life Review Team
Drawing Supplies
Related Reads
  • Creative Arts and Crafts Ideas for More At-Home Fun With Your Kids
  • 6 Hand Lettering Fonts To Try On Your Next Stationary Project
  • 10 Painting Ideas for Kids They Are Sure to Love
  • Art Tips: How To Blend Colored Pencils
Back to top
logo

©2025. All Rights Reserved

  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Terms
Contact

[email protected]

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Click here to learn more about our process.